Scientists have been creating partly human chimeras for years. Researchers use rats with human tumors to study cancer, for example, and mice with human immune systems to conduct AIDS research.
---What makes the latest experiment unique is that the scientists injected human stem cells, which can become any kind of tissue, into an embryo of a primate.
“It does show that the human stem cells tend to migrate far and wide through the monkey embryo,” says Insoo Hyun, a bioethicist who is
involved in international oversight of such research. “That is what leads to the theoretical concern: There is a chance that in an uncontrolled way it may lead to a mixing of human cells that may result in human cells developing in the brain or the heart or from head to toe across the body.” That means researchers can’t target the stem cells to create specific organs or avoid random changes to the animal’s brain—at least not yet.In a glimpse of the potential effects, researchers at the University of Rochester in 2014 transplanted human fetal brain cells called astrocytes into young laboratory mice. They discovered that within a year the human cells had taken over the mouse brains. Moreover, standard tests for mouse memory and cognition showed that the altered mice were smarter.
In his 2006 State of the Union Address, President George W. Bush called the creation of human-animal hybrids one of “the most egregious abuses of medical research.” Seven countries ban or restrict it. Since 2015, the U.S. National Institutes of Health has refused to fund experiments that involve human stem cells added to early animal embryos.
Policy makers, however, might relax some restrictions this year. An NIH spokeswoman says that the organization is awaiting the
release next month of updated guidelines from the International Society for Stem Cell Research “to ensure our position reflects the input from the community, which has been very thoughtful.” The agency lifted restrictions on fetal-tissue research earlier this month.